Justices harlan and blackmun and chief justice burger dis sented. It seems that in the attempts to compare this case to the pentagon papers, the essential distinction between. Paul bender t the brethren is an account of the inner workings of the supreme court from 1969 to 1976the first seven years of warren e. Greenhouse has mined blackmuns private papers brilliantly to create a moving. Chief justice burger, along with justices harlan and blackmun, supported the governments position.
Reading the pentagon papers is like watching a movie and the ending is already known. On his death in 1999, writes new york times supreme court correspondent greenhouse, harry blackmun gave the library of congress his papers, contained in 1,585 boxes that take up more than six hundred feet. Supreme court by president nixon, became a highly regarded justice usually taking a middleoftheroad position. Focusing on the back story of the pentagon papers and the resulting court cases, it draws upon a wealth of oral history and previously classified documents to show the consequences of leak and litigation both for the vietnam war and for. Wade, according to papers of the late justice harry blackmun released thursday. Paul area of minnesota where his father, corwin manning blackmun, was a. The pentagon papers was the topsecret department of defense study of our nations political and military involvement in vietnam from 1945 to 1967.
Justice blackmun but i am not prepared to reach the merits. The outsider justice offers an indepth, revelatory portrait of one of the most intriguing jurists ever to sit on the supreme court. The supreme court came close to virtually overturning roe v. The pentagon papers in the federal courts the case in context a short narrative o n june, 1971, the new york times stunned the nation by publishing a frontpage story headlined, vietnam archive. Katharine graham the post true story how she changed. Blackmun participated in the pentagon papers case new york times v. Harry blackmun s supreme court journey view larger image. Blackmun wrote opinions of significance in four areas.
The pentagon papers case has given rise to two opposing narratives that reflect the. Heres what the trailblazer was like in real lifeand how the washington post and a set. Becoming justice blackmun by linda greenhouse kirkus. The untold story of the pentagon papers coconspirators the. Blackmun also played an important role in a number of deathpenalty decisions. With well over ten years of marketing and branding our content, pentagon publishing has built a trusted name in this domain. Book recommendations, author interviews, editors picks, and more. Court rules for newspapers, 63 the washington post. I think now we can go out there and say thats done. Guided by the domino theory if vietnam fell to communist so would the rest of asia, the us government acted as if vietnam was the last redoubt.
He is best known for writing the majority opinion in roe v. The late justice harry blackmun meticulously kept a mountain of files during his 24 years on the supreme court, including notes on the 1973 roe v. The three dissenters also argued that sensitive and complex foreign policy decisions of the sort raised in the pentagon papers case should be undertaken only by those directly responsible to the people whose welfare. Dec 23, 2017 when washington post reporters showed up at ben bradlees house in georgetown to sift through the pentagon papers, his 10yearold daughter marina really was outside selling lemonade. This is the lesson of the pentagon papers experience, and it may be relevant now.
Wade, and participated in the most contentious debates of his eraall behind closed doors. Texts of the supreme court decision, opinions and dissents. Justice harry blackmun even raised the possibility that their publication. Burgers tenure as chief justice of the united states. The complete pentagon papers online national archives site report of the office of the secretary of defense vietnam task force 7,000 pages in pdf format first made fully available to public in 2011 excerpt. Five years to the day after his death, 1,576 boxes of blackmuns papers and 38 hours of tapes of his oral history are released to the public. The ruling made it possible for the new york times and the washington post newspapers to publish the thenclassified pentagon papers without risk of government censorship or punishment. The justice s identification with the marginalized members of society arguably provides the overarching key to that consistency. The pentagon papers was the name given to a topsecret department of defense study of u.
The swirling storm around wikileaks today reinforces the need to defend the right of all media to reveal the truth. The pentagon papers 2003, directed by rod holcomb and executive produced by joshua d. In 1971 former cold war hardliner daniel ellsberg made history by releasing the pentagon papersa 7,000page topsecret study of u. The secret history of the vietnam war neil sheehan, herick smith, e. Article ii of the great document vests in the executive branch primary power over the conduct of foreign affairs and places in that branch the responsibility for the nations safety. Justice holmes, dissenting in northern securities co. The book has the actual memos and papers written by those us government officials involved in directing the war. Dec 07, 2010 quote in its landmark ruling in the pentagon papers case, the us supreme court said only a free and unrestrained press can effectively expose deception in government. Campbell, 1 book meiklejohn civil liberties institute. Paul area of minnesota where his father, corwin manning blackmun, was. Speaking publicly for the first time, a historian reveals the crucial role that he and a small band of others played in helping daniel.
In first amendment cases, although he dissented from the courts ruling that stopped the government from repressing the pentagon papers, he overturned a gag order imposed by a nebraska court prohibiting commentary or reporting on a murder trial nebraska press association v. A pulitzer prizewinning correspondent with unprecedented access to the inner workings of the u. Quote in its landmark ruling in the pentagon papers case. Supreme court chronicles the personal transformation of a legendary justicefrom 1970 to 1994, justice harry a. Blackmun papers, container 648, folder 5, library of congress, washington, d. Harry andrew blackmun 19081997 served as an associate justice on the u. Inside the pentagon papers reexamines what happened, why it mattered, and why it still has relevance today. Inside the pentagon papers by john prados, paperback barnes. Henkin, louis, the right to know and the duty to withhold. The day that former president lyndon johnson died, january 22, 1973, justice harry blackmun announced the supreme courts 7to2 decision in roe v. Quote in its landmark ruling in the pentagon papers. Blackmun, which are expected to add to knowledge of the courts interpretation of constitutional law over three decades, open to the public on march 4 in the manuscript division of the library of congress. In his dissenting opinion in the pentagon papers case, mr. High profile outlets help with the discoverability of our titles.
Justice harry blackmun the first amendment, after all, is only one part of an entire constitution. The new york times, first article on the pentagon papers, 39. Shown is the correction of the phrase, i no longer shall tinker with the machinery of death. Gloria bartnicki, a negotiator for the teachers union in wyoming valley, pennsylvania, was recorded in a private conversation. But then, almost 30 years later, an unsettling jolt finally kicked in. But the fact remains that when jfk was alive and in office the number of american military personnel in vietnam was around 16,000. In 1971 sheehan published in the new york times controversial details from the classified pentagon papers regarding the war in vietnam. Salter, 1 book john prados, 1 book susan dudley gold, 1 book peter schrag, 1 book peter a.
In june of 1971, small portions of the report were leaked to the press and widely distributed. This conflict was very evident in the pentagon papers case, also known as new york times co. The author admits that blackmun s importance as a subject for judicial biography is largely predicated on his landmark opinion in roe v. The pentagon papers in the federal courts 2e federal judicial.
The ruling made it possible for the new york times and the washington post newspapers to publish the thenclassified pentagon papers. However, the publications of the report that resulted from these leaks were incomplete and suffered from many quality issues. With the precedent of the pentagon papers decisions, it would have been impossible now to prevent the publication of those papers. The majority of the supreme court said that although they would not stop publication in advance, the question of whether there could be prosecution afterwards was a completely different thing. The brief judgment was read to a hushed courtroom by chief justice warren.
Wade the slightly longer answer can be found in the 2005 national bestseller becoming justice blackmun. Beacon press, 1971 the contents of this volume are drawn from the official record of the u. Becoming justice blackmun harry blackmuns supreme court. The pentagon papers, officially titled report of the office of the secretary of defense vietnam task force, was commissioned by secretary of defense robert mcnamara in 1967. Wade 1973 that overturned most state abortion laws. A page from justice blackmun s draft dissent in the death penalty case, callins v. Historically, the supreme court has disagreed on the limitations that can be placed on the first amendment. However, thomas spoke positively of blackmun when he appeared in 2001 at the dedication of the harry a. As new york times reporter linda greenhouse shows in her new biography, becoming justice blackmun. Seven films to stream if you loved the post nyt watching. Wade 1973 that established constitutional protection of abortion. When blackmun s papers were released at the library of congress, his sometimes negative notations regarding fellow justice clarence thomas came to light. Harry blackmun was the third minnesotan to serve on the us supreme court, after pierce butler associate justice, 19231939 and warren burger chief justice, 19691986, and he stayed the longest. The book says jfk continued americas involvement in vietnam.
Burger, who announced the edict along with his own dissent and the dissents of justices john m. Mar 04, 2004 the supreme court came close to virtually overturning roe v. So clear are the constitutional limitations on prior restraint against expression that, from the time of near v. Supreme court, 63, upholds newspapers on publication of pentagon report thursday, july 1, 1971 special to the new york times ashington, june 30 the supreme court freed the new york times and the washington post today to resume immediate publication of articles based on the secret pentagon papers on the origins of the vietnam war. The papers reveal justice anthony kennedy played a key. Triangulating the boundaries of the pentagon papers. In seeking injunctions against these newspapers and in its presentation to the court, the. Maurer, is a historical film made for fx, in association with paramount television and city entertainment, about the pentagon papers and daniel ellsbergs involvement in their publication. In dissent, chief justice burger and justices blackmun and harlan complained about the haste with which the case was decided. In the pages of his latest book, yarbrough provides an absorbing account of justice harry blackmun s life and work with particular focus on his us supreme court years. Nixon, 1974 and other constitutional controversies about congressional powers and federalstate relations.
These cases forcefully call to mind the wise admonition of mr. From the pentagon papers, gravel edition, volume 4, chapter 1, the air war in vietnam. The pentagon papers gravel edition volume 1 chapter i, background to the crisis, 194050, pp. Were republicanappointed justices who favored roe in 1973. Connecticut 1965, which formulated a right of privacy based in part on emanations from the first amendment. Washington, june 30following is the text of the decision by the united states supreme court upholding the new york times and the washington post against an effort by the federal government to. Justice harry blackmun even raised the possibility that their publication would lead to the prolongation of the war and the death of soldiers, the destruction of alliances, the. Justices burger, blackmun, and harlan objected and justices black, brennan, douglas, marshall, stewart, and white agreed. The media led with johnsons passing, while blackmun, in his. The appearance of the pentagon papers on the front page of the newspaper on sunday, june, 1971, infuriated president richard nixon. The secret history of the vietnam war sheehan, neil, smith, hedrick, kenworthy, e. It is re quested that you natiiy all recipients to whom addit. The government contends that the only issue in these cases is whether, in a suit by the united states, the first amendment bars a court from prohibiting a newspaper from publishing material whose disclosure would pose a grave and immediate danger to the security of the united states.
The storm of controversy he had created revolved not around the secrets he had disclosed, but rather the legal and political issues raised by nixons war against the times. The life and times of a supreme court justice who resisted easy categorization, then and now. Biographies on harry blackmun research papers on harry. Both the history and language of the first amendment support the view that the press must be left free to publish news, whatever the source, without censorship, injunctions, or. The papers of supreme court associate justice harry a. National security archive electronic briefing book no. Feb 07, 2018 the scandals of the pentagon papers and watergate, coupled with a general post60s distrust of authority and institution, led to a miniboom of taut, paranoid conspiracy thrillers like the.
This book provides a brief and manageable collection of the most important documents on u. The ruling made it possible for the new york times and the washington post newspapers to publish the thenclassified pentagon papers without risk of government censorship or punishment president richard nixon had claimed executive authority to force the. Jun, 2011 when you read most stories about the pentagon papers, the last line always is, the defense department has yet to declassify the papers. In this piece, david dunlap, a metro reporter, reflects on the 45th anniversary of the historic victory for freedom of the press. The supreme court ended up with a 63 vote against a prior restraint affecting the publication of the pentagon papers. The book relies exclusively on the extensive collection of personal and official papers donated in blackmun s will to. A memoir of vietnam and the pentagon papers daniel. Becoming justice blackmun is essentially a book length treatment of these same three subjects, and thus, as its author readily admits, is neither a full biography nor a complete account of a. In addition to the new york times company, the justice department named. Dec, 2018 the pentagon papers, as they became known, also set into motion of chain of events that would lead to the watergate scandals which began the following year. Thoroughly researched, engagingly written, harry a. The only mystery after the oral argument was how the courts center would vote. The posting today by the national security archive at george washington university, allows for a unique sidebyside comparison, showing readers exactly what the u.
Blackmun was born november 12, 1908, in nashville, illinois, but spent his youth in the minneapolisst. Small wonder the us government fought so hard to suppress these damning documents. Feb 27, 2018 the post depicts katharine grahams historicand riskylegal battle to publish the pentagon papers. For the first time ever, all three major editions of the pentagon papers are being made available simultaneously online. In clear and forceful prose, becoming justice blackmun tells a judicial horatio alger story and a tale of a remarkable transformation.
The pentagon papers case essay custom university papers. The pentagon papers supreme court briefs and opinions. Justice black commended the new york times and the washington post for publishing the pentagon papers. In the past, there has always been conflict between the free press and the government. I dont really see a lot in this massive book about the pentagon papers to make me doubt those conspiracy theories. Drawing on this wealth of primary information, greenhouse turns in a nuanced study of. Louis federal courthouse, mentioning that blackmun drove a. Justice, that to me it is equally obvious that no law does not mean no. Jan 29, 2018 the untold story of the pentagon papers coconspirators. Rehnquist, the supreme court 259 first vintage books. The chief justice was one of the dissenters along with associate justices harry a. Jun 30, 2016 times insider shares historic insights from the new york times. The short answer is that he was an associate justice of the united supreme court and the author of roe v.
At the time of his gift, blackmun stipulated that the papers should not be opened to the general public until five years after his death. United states 1971, also called the pentagon papers case, defended the first amendment right of. Blackmun wrote that he shared the concern of a lower court judge that publication of the papers could clearly result. Hugo lafayette black february 27, 1886 september 25, 1971 was an american lawyer, politician, and jurist who served as a u. He was little known outside legal circles until he wrote the decision in roe v. Mar 08, 2004 blackmun papers reveal for the first time that in 1992 justice anthony kennedy was nearly a fifth vote to all but overturn roe v. Jun, 2011 in 1971, parts of a secret pentagon report began to surface in the new york times calling the vietnam wars validity into question. The pentagon papers case and the wikileaks controversy. Blackmun and burgher were conservatives in 1973 the former defecting left in the 1980s and 1990s, and stewart and powell were moderates.
Justice harlan, with whom the chief justice and mr. Senator from 1927 to 1937 and as an associate justice. The governments witnesses testified that the pentagon papers were indeed classified top secret, that daniel ellsberg had signed a security statement with rand promising not to transmit classified information to an unauthorized person or agency, and that neither anthony russo or linda sinay had any security clearances. Blackmun 19081999 wrote numerous landmark supreme court decisions, including roe v. Inevitably political, the pentagon papers case is a decisive test of the federal governments capacity to control the disclosure of information stamped secret, of an individuals right to. Washington, june 30following is the text of the decision by the united states supreme court upholding the new york times and the washington post against an. In 1997, justice blackmun gave his personal papers to the united states for inclusion in the collections of the library. Day to day, march 4, 2004 the battle to preserve roe.
Forty years later, the pentagon papers were declassified and. Chief justice burger, along with justices harlan and blackmun, supported the. And there was no statute on the books indicating that congress ever intended to. Supreme court, 63, upholds newspapers on publication of. The moral of the pentagon papers case is that constant vigilance in defense of the first amendment is necessary all the more so, as chief justice hughes wrote many years ago, in. The pentagon papers were out, showing the murder and the lying machine for what they were. Quote in its landmark ruling in the pentagon papers case, the us supreme court said only a free and unrestrained press can effectively expose deception in government. And there was no statute on the books indicating that congress ever intended to enjoin publication of this less damaging sort. Sheehan joined the new york times in 1964 and reported from indonesia and again vietnam before becoming the pentagon correspondent in 1966.
1102 1402 134 1217 80 10 1359 1326 654 755 1054 557 1541 1201 959 1002 259 654 868 110 1369 1075 1081 872 564 1272 1160 87 918 995